| [ | Tags | | | books | ] |
| [ | Current Location |
| | The Office | ] |
| [ | mood |
| | okay | ] |
| [ | music |
| | Meeting Room | ] |

PERFIDY by Ben Hecht
PERFIDY, Ben Hecht’s passionate exculpation of the “Kastner Affair” (a 1953 trial that remains radioactively controversial to this day) is itself the subject of intense debate, and was banned in Israel for decades. What we know for sure is this: Rudolph Kastner, head of the Jewish Aid and Rescue Committee, somehow persuaded the Nazis to allow about 1600 of his fellow Hungarian Jews (including Kastner’s family and many of his prominent peers) to escape to Switzerland in 1943. A decade later, an elderly amateur journalist living in Israel asserted that this great good was done in exchange for a greater evil—that to secure these escapes, Kastner had agreed to help the SS keep the other Jews in Hungary ignorant of their destination at Auschwitz. The government of Israel sued the accusing journalist for libel, arguing that Kastner’s deal with the SS was merely part of the Nazis' strategy to develop humanitarian “alibis” in preparation for their now-inevitable arrests at the end of the war. But whatever Kastner’s intent, his self-asserted dealings with the Nazis (as well as his role in the exoneration of SS Officer Kurt Becher, who dodged war-criminal status thanks to an affidavit from Kastner) eventually saw him labeled as a collaborator by a number of Israeli citizens—even though the Israeli Supreme Court would not uphold the charges. In PERFIDY, Hecht weaves the Kastner Affair into a tapestry of conspiracy, intimating that the Hungarian Jews were essentially permitted to die by Israel’s Zionist elite, who hoped to hold onto power by helping British superiors enforce their strict cap on Jewish immigration to Palestine. Hecht even goes so far as to suggest that the Zionists nixed operations to save Jews from Hungary, and did their best to keep news of the holocaust’s extent from leaking out abroad. The Jewish Agency’s response to PERFIDY flatly states that this is all fiction, and to be fair, Hecht is a screenwriter, not a historian; his book reads like a film treatment, specifically one by Oliver Stone. Hecht’s also prone (like all the machination-minded) to attribute sinister motives to choices that may not have been choices: What’s perceived as the Zionists’ unwillingness to inform the world about the camps may have been the unwillingness of the world to listen, and his assertion that The Jewish Agency’s bureaucratic cross-purposes masked an unwillingness to rescue Hungarian Jews could have simply been managerial incapability. In short, what Hecht regards as strategic indifference may have just been failure, plain and simple. Yet, as with any good conspiracy theory, the fishiness will not entirely wash off. Though it’s been revealed that many of Hecht’s source materials are selectively quoted, Kastner’s testimony from the libel trial is included in long tracts, and it’s pretty damning. Plus there’s the fact that Kastner’s personal trial never had the chance to happen—he was assassinated before it could. Hecht’s self-admittedly biased account of these events will have many readers seeing red, but they may find that it soon fades to an unsettling shade of gray. |